Juror discharged for discussing mushroom trial with family, friends

Blogs
Blog Calender Image
May 15, 2025

A juror has been discharged from the Erin Patterson trial after it emerged he had been discussing the case with family and friends.

The male juror was formally released from the panel of 15 jurors on Thursday morning by Justice Christopher Beale.

Justice Beale said there was a "reasonable possibility" information about the juror discussing the case with outsiders was credible but no findings had been reached as to the man’s possible misconduct.

Justice Beale told the remaining jurors confidential discussions were "vital to the administration of justice".

"I want to remind you of my directions. You should only discuss the case with your fellow jurors in the privacy of the jury room," he said.

ADVERTISEMENT

Fourteen jurors remained on the case.

When all the evidence had been presented, two other jurors would be balloted off to leave a final 12 to decide whether Erin Patterson was guilty or acquitted of murder and attempted murder charges.

The 50-year-old has been charged with three counts of murder and one of attempted murder over the July 29, 2023 meal but she has pleaded not guilty, claiming the meal was a terrible accident.

More on this topic

Death cap mushroom sightings near venue of fatal meal

Mushroom expert Dr Thomas May discussed the origins of amanita phalloides, known as death cap mushrooms, and how "citizen scientists" often shared their whereabouts on websites.

Crime and Justice

Tue, May 13

Tears, laughter as family front mushroom murder trial

Tensions were high as the only guest to survive a deadly mushroom lunch at Erin Patterson's home walked the few steps to the witness box.

Crime and Justice

Sat, May 10

2:17

Mushroom cook felt 'isolated' from former in-laws, court hears

Alleged triple murderer Erin Patterson has said she felt 'isolated' from in-laws prior to serving them a poisonous beef Wellington dish.

Crime and Justice

5:07pm

Her estranged husband Simon Patterson's parents, Don and Gail, and his aunty Heather Wilkinson all died in hospital from death cap mushroom poisoning after eating toxic beef Wellingtons.

The only survivor from the lunch was Heather's husband Ian.

Get Insurance Now